A Race Apart: the beauty queens of the apartheid era

June 25, 2010

The Miss World finalists are now at the World Cup, but the women who represented South Africa in its past have divided memories

So far the game has not been beautiful for the World Cup’s “33rd official team”. They have gone largely unnoticed in South Africa’s impressive new stadiums, despite displaying frozen grins, tiny T-shirts and little resentment at being overshadowed by the men on the pitch.
This team are not footballers, but 31 Miss World finalists who arrived in Johannesburg two weeks ago to join their national squads on a mutual journey that will, for one, end in victory, fame and wealth.

Their intervention in this most testosterone-driven of tournaments is, ostensibly, to promote “Beauty with a Purpose”, now a central theme of Miss World, and a point enthusiastically endorsed by President Zuma when he emerged, looking smitten, from a meeting with Miss South Africa, Nicole Flint. Reflecting on how she, as a white person, felt about representing South Africa at the World Cup, Flint said: “It is not a black 2010. It’s about two races coming together, it’s about a nation coming together and it’s about being an example to the rest of the world to show them that we as South Africa can do this.”

But in this unlikely melting-pot of sport and lip-gloss something is missing — any reminder of the women who competed to represent South Africa at a time when the nation was committed to keeping races apart. From 1970 to 1977, while South Africa tetered on the brink of meltdown with brutal government oppression and township uprisings, international pressure forced the apartheid regime to send two finalists to the pageant — one white, and one black. The result was a catwalk battle that propelled some of the women to stardom, but broke others.

“When I got on to the victory podium I raised my fist,” Cynthia Shange says. “It was a black power salute. I got into a lot of trouble for that.” She was a Zulu girl from Lamontville, Durban’s oldest African township. In 1972 Shange boarded her first airplane, sipped a glass of champagne, and went to London. She was to take the stage at the Royal Albert Hall for Miss World, in what was then a huge glamourfest — but not as Miss South Africa.
“I was Miss Africa South,” Shange says. “In the Albert Hall two of us appeared under the same flag, but everything was upside down. I was representing a country that did not exist, there is no Africa South.” Beside her on stage — though kept apart for official photographs — was Stephanie Reinecke, a long-haired blonde who was also from Natal. “I got on well with Stephanie,” Shange says. “We were close, we talked about make-up and music and we kept in touch after we got back.”

But their circumstances could not have been more different: Reinecke was the official Miss South Africa, having been crowned in Johannesburg City Hall. Shange says: “I can’t help feeling robbed. Of course I feel that I should have had the right to be Miss South Africa.”

That Shange was able to take part in the contest at all was largely because of one man, Harry Solarsh, who owned a South African clothing company and sponsored Miss Africa South.

“Harry felt the mixed-race and black girls should have something too,” says Doreen Levin, a veteran reporter who wrote about Miss South Africa during the 1970s and 1980s for the Johannesburg Sunday Times newspaper.
Levin is now writing a book about the history of South African beauty pageants. Miss Africa South was established as a non-white contest and Miss South Africa was strictly for whites only. “You have to understand Miss South Africa and Miss Africa South were two different contests,” she says.

According to the South African sociologist Deborah Posel, who runs the Institute for Humanities in Africa at the University of Cape Town, Miss South Africa and Miss Africa South were “a very apartheid idea. It was unthinkable to have an idea of beauty that encompassed all races. Black people were allowed to see themselves as beautiful, but white people weren’t allowed to see black people as beautiful. It was yet another apartheid oddity — a completely irrational expression of prejudice. Black people had their own contest — but it was second-class beauty.”

Shange was the third winner of Miss Africa South to attend Miss World, but the first African. The two women who preceded her were mixed-race girls from Cape Town, who were referred to as “Coloured”. Shange says that she would have failed the notorious apartheid pencil test, in which “Africaness” was measured by whether a pencil stuck in someone’s hair would stay in or drop out. “My hair is curly. God made it that way. It is beautiful. I have a flat nose. God made it that way, it is beautiful,” Shange says.

When she returned from her victory tour, however, South Africa did not think she was beautiful. “I got a modeling contract working with the Solarsh company. But when I travelled around the country I had to stop at roadhouses to eat and ask for food through the back door. There were stages I couldn’t appear on, doors I couldn’t go through, restaurants I couldn’t eat in.”

In New York she had been staggered when a white waiter offered to take off her coat. In South Africa the media were trained to pretend she didn’t exist. Other winners of Miss Africa South found the contrast too hard to bear,some slipping into obscurity, alcoholism, or becoming involved in religion.
“When they came back there was nothing,” says Maureen Edwards, who won Miss Africa South in the 1960s before it became part of Miss World. “Modeling contracts went to the white girls, even if they’d been lower placed.”

Miss Africa South was usually recognised with an open-topped car-ride, and a warm welcome in the non-white press, “but then back to the factory, or wherever they had been before”.

“We took some photos together, but we went to different functions when we got back. That was how it was and I never questioned the fact,” Anneline Kriel says, recalling her non-white counterpart in the contest of 1974.
Kriel became a South African icon. The blonde prison officer’s daughter from the mining town of Witbank shot from “coal dust to stardust” by taking the Miss World crown after the British winner Helen Morgan was disqualified because she was an unwed mother.

“They came to offer me the crown and I wasn’t sure I wanted to take it. My steady boyfriend at the time was against it. He was training to be a priest in the Dutch Reformed Church and he said it would break us up. And it did.”
Kriel accepted, but in her own way was also to undergo a tortuous journey. With an international boycott of South Africa gathering steam, Kriel was vilified by the international media as the face of an apartheid nation; beaming on stage in a gold cloak of South African Krugerrands while her black countrymen suffered.

After Kriel’s surprise victory, the US and Australia refused to accept her as part of the obligatory world tour, while other nations protested that they could not guarantee her safety.

“Shirley Bassey protested when I won,” Kriel says, offering no excuses for her ignorance of the politics of the time. In the sheltered world of a conservative Afrikaner town, with a heavily censored press, she had little exposure to the turmoil in the townships, or the opinions of the outside world. “I was 19. I was very innocent. When I finally went to America they asked me on TV if I thought everyone in my country was happy — and I said yes, I did think everyone was happy. Because I did think that.”

At a loss as to what to do with her, the Miss World organisers sent Kriel to a series of events at Mecca bingo halls in Margate and Southampton. While she speaks fondly of her time in England, Doreen Levin says it was a lonely, isolating and confusing experience: “She didn’t really speak much English, and she had to translate everything into Afrikaans and then back into English again.”

Back home Kriel received a warmer welcome, stepping off the plane into instant adulation; the coronation of an archetypal blonde South African princess was a propaganda coup — a symbolic two-fingers to a world that otherwise offered nothing but condemnation. Kriel remembers that crowds would gather in front of TV shop windows to see her: “We were too poor to have a television, but my dad used to go down and watch my interviews through the store window, and say to people: ‘That’s my daughter’.”
“There was not a lot else happening for white South Africa at the time,”Deborah Posel recalls.

If she was a political pawn of the time, Kriel now says her Miss World victory did little to enhance what became a successful international modeling career. Overseas her status as a famous former beauty queen was something she “kept quiet about”. At home, however, relentless media interest in her life meant that “quiet” was never an adjective employed. Kriel remains one of the most talked about figures of white South Africa; a self-made star who stayed in the headlines by marrying and divorcing the hotel and casino magnate Sol Kerzner, acting in a Hollywood martial arts film, releasing a pop record, and finally settling down with her third husband in Cape Town. “She has not exactly lived a humdrum life,” Levin says.

If memory of her victory in the white South African imagination remains undimmed, “she is actually a very nice woman,” Posel says. “She is not stuck up, and she’s unaffected”. Kriel now devotes her time to a charity that works with street children, and says: “As a country we are now in a much better place than we were then.”

With no such fanfare, Cynthia Shange found the adjustment of returning to life in South Africa difficult — but in time she also became a national icon.
“When I was overseas and saw people of different races mixing together I thought, ‘God, will things ever change in my country’?” Shange says.

As a finalist in Miss World she had been granted a passport — a rarity for black South Africans — and allowed to travel across Europe and America, on condition that she refrained from talking about politics. But seeing first-hand the freedoms that she knew she could not enjoy in her own country was painful. “When I got home I had to tell myself to adjust or I knew it would disturb my mind.” Shange married and divorced a well-known local journalist — “married for the first and the last time” — and became an actress. In 1972 she was the first black woman to be featured in South Africa’s most popular magazine, Fair Lady and is now known for her role in the soap opera Muhvango. In 2009 Shange accepted a lifetime award at the South African Film and Television Awards.

The opportunities for her were great, but the opposition bitter. In total seven Miss Africa Souths attended Miss World between 1970 and 1977, but they found themselves the focal point of rancorous disputes within their own communities from those who believed that taking part alongside a white-only Miss South Africa legitimised apartheid. At its height the contest was held in secret because of fears of rioting. Finally, in 1977, all South African participation was withdrawn from Miss World after several countries threatened a boycott. The country did not return until apartheid began to crumble in 1990.

None of the Miss World finalists now visiting Johannesburg will remember the days before democracy. Those attending the 2010 World Cup have been dutifully visiting children’s hospitals, promoting issues as incongruous as local bus transport, and tooting their vuvuzelas for a beauty contest that may no longer scale the heights of a pageant once compered by Bob Hope and transmitted from the Albert Hall — but which still has the power to divide the world.

(Miss World organisers were forced to switch the grand final from Nigeria to London in 2002 after a newspaper suggested that the Prophet Muhammad might have chosen a wife from among the contestants, an article blamed for sparking religious riots in which 200 people died.) In Miss World tradition, this year’s finalists span a multicultural chasm, respecting all nations, and appearing on the pitch at Soccer City in Johannesburg in minuscule shorts.

“I am grateful to Harry Solarsh for fighting so hard to put us on the map,” Shange says, “even though we felt like we were being done a favour.” Despite all that she went through Shange says that Miss Africa South and Miss World opened the door to a new life for her; although it was not one open to all her fellow contestants. “When I got back I suffered, but I look at my daughter and I’m so proud. She goes wherever, she stands on any stage, travels overseas. Nothing is impossible for her.”
For those who were Miss South Africa and Miss Africa South the tumultuous 1970s were a surreal combination of limousines, champagne, fake lashes and swimsuit contests mixed with politics, protests and brutal oppression.

“All I can say,” Shange says, “is that it was an experience that will remain with me until I die.”

Comments (12)

Posted by: Doreen Levin over 7 years ago

Brilliant, Karen. You gave a very fair, well researched and accurate account. I am sure that whoever reads this story will be fascinated. Thankyou for taking the time to find me, and also for mentioning my book which you re-motivated me to re-write and complete, which I greatly appreciate.

Posted by: Doreen Levin over 7 years ago

Brilliant, Karen. You gave a very fair, well researched and accurate account. I am sure that whoever reads this story will be fascinated. Thankyou for taking the time to find me, and also for mentioning my book which you re-motivated me to re-write and complete, which I greatly appreciate.

Posted by: Doreen Levin over 7 years ago

Brilliant, Karen. You gave a very fair, well researched and accurate account. I am sure that whoever reads this story will be fascinated. Thankyou for taking the time to find me, and also for mentioning my book which you re-motivated me to re-write and complete, which I greatly appreciate.

Posted by: ANNELINE BACON (Kriel) over 6 years ago

Dear Karin, Thank you for treating the interview in a objective manner and writing the article in a non bias and fair way. After reading it all I can say is: We come a long way baby!!

Posted by: ANNELINE BACON (Kriel) over 6 years ago

Dear Karin, Thank you for treating the interview in a objective manner and writing the article in a non bias and fair way. After reading it all I can say is: We come a long way baby!!

Posted by: Donna Howard (Ellesmere Port, UK) over 4 years ago

Was 1974 the only Miss World contest where the contestants were required to walk barefoot in the swimsuit round? I remember the girls looked far more natural than when their feet were crushed into high heels.

Posted by: Amanda-Jill Kershaw over 4 years ago

Donna, you’re quite right to point out that girls look more natural without artificial aids!

There’s an air of falseness surrounding most beauty contests. I remember a televised Miss Great Britain competition in the 1980s when the swimsuit parade took place around a swimming pool. The girls were then asked to dive in; only two could (and did) do so!

Posted by: Zac over 4 years ago

Where can I get hold of Doreen Levin’s book ? I collect photos and newspaper clippings of Miss South Africa, Miss Africa South, Miss RSA and Miss Universe South Africa winners. I recently purchased an original photo of Rosette Motsepe Miss Africa South 1976 and made contact with Rosette on Facebook. My favorite SA beauty queen of all times is Anneline Kriel. I have a photo album starting with Molly Lamont Miss South Africa (unofficial) 1930 up to 2011. The album is not complete but I am hpoing to complete it in the future. Thanks for the interesting article. Rgs Zac

Posted by: Katie over 3 years ago

Dear Karen

I only came across this article now. I really enjoyed it and wondered if there has been any follow up articles/research since then, by yourself or Doreen Levin?
Kind reagrds
Katie

Posted by: Gordon Dally over 2 years ago

I understand that my sister Mavis Dally was runner up to Molly Lamont who was the South African Beauty Queen from Boksburg. I have a photo of my sister. Are you able to help if confirm this regards Gordon Dally.

Posted by: Rania Kadret ( Miss Iraq 2001) over 2 years ago

I loved the article, I think Iraq shares alot since we faced a similar issue, being instated as a state in 1918 and declared Independent from Britain in 1921, power was in the hands of Caucasian Iraqis who were a minority, most came from Georgia, Azerbaijan, Daghistan , Armenia, they were allowed settlement by the Ottoman Empire, and then elevated and supported by the British. My grandparents were from the former Soviet Republic of Georgia. In Iraq, Slavery was abolished in 1958, not too long ago, we had an issue of racism as well, it was more subtle and not as blunt as Apartheid South Africa but nevertheless, it was there, Arabs and Coloured people, Shiites, Kurds, Blacks were regarded as second or even third class citizens, they were mistreated by the minority White population. We even had two separate pageants, one for the Caucasian girls called “MISS IRAQ” and one for the rest called " Maiden of Beauty".

I won the contest in 2001, which is a long way from that era, but I can relate to the article in someway.

Much love

Rania Kadret
Facebook: www.facebook.com/Rania.Kadret

I have a question for Anneline Kriel: Did you receive the entire prize package, trophy, sash of Miss World and what was it like being Miss World in a time when your country was facing political turmoil, because I won in a time when my country was politically Isolated as well, and I did not take part in Miss World 2001.

Posted by: Sally Ann Fawcett over 2 years ago

Karen, this is the best article about the South African pageant era of the 1970s I have ever read.
My book, Misdemeanours: Beauty Queen Scandals (Amazon) highlights in particular the 1970 Miss World contest, in which every controversial element of that time came into play: accusations of results-fixing, the feminist protests of flour bombs and of course apartheid between the two South African contestants.
A fascinating topic – and Doreen, I really do hope you finish your own book too!

Add your comment:

Archive

Recent Posts

Welcome

Welcome to my website. I hope these pages give you a flavour of some of my work in books, print, onl…

Recent News

Istanbul Arrival

Last week I was in Istanbul attending a Youth Forum for teenagers from around the world. But not eve…

Nelson Mandela Dies - Grazia

When Nelson Mandela retired after serving one five-year term as President of South Africa in 1999 he…

China Debates....

I’ve just returned from China, after a gap of about 16 years, and I met these undergraduates – comin…

Top Ten Articles

Polio's Last Stand

Eradicating the Last 1% of Polio Is Deadly But Essential

When 40-year-old Liberian civil servan…

Life and Love with 'The Greatest': Muhammad Ali

When Yolanda “Lonnie” Williams was six years old she looked out of her front door in Louisville,…

Momma D: Dionne Warwick, the Grande Dame of Divas

She learnt her stagecraft from Marlene Dietrich; 50 years on, she’s mentor to Whitney Houston and …

India's Barefoot Revolution

What would it be like if women ran the world? In some parts of India, it’s already happening

If…

How one man gave Congo’s women hope

*Life is hell for women caught up in the conflict in the Congo. But one remarkable doctor helps surv…

‘If they gave me a house, I’d take it tomorrow’

All I want is to die under this mountain.” Noor Ebrahim, a slightly-built former messenger for Rea…

It’s murder on your mobile, says The Killing’s Sarah Lund

Hit crime drama The Killing is back for a second series, and Karen Bartlett talks mobile phone foren…

Skateistan: How skateboarding took off with Afghan kids

It’s no surprise that in a world full of rules most kids want to do something with no organisation…

Growing Up X

Fifty years after he was killed, the daughter of Malcolm X wants to make sure her father isn’t writt…

Bringing Anne Frank Home – to Germany

Like many people in their seventies and eighties, Buddy Elias and his wife Gertie are downsizing –…


©2011 Karen Bartlett | Goodcleanfunk